TL;DR: Go for an Eliminator, DW 500 or Iron Cobra 900 and you'll (most likely) be happy.
I have played the same Pearl Eliminator for 21 years now. Still going strong. Between the different cams and a chain / belt option, it's a great way to experiment getting different feels.
For many years I played a blue cam with a chain. A couple of years ago I was in an experimental phase, changed to a belt drive and white cam, loosened the springs... Felt like a totally different pedal.
I recently bought a used Tama Iron Cobra 900, and that thing's a pleasure to play on as well.